Ask questions like this to multiple AIs at once

Try free

Differential diagnosis practice cases

Here are three interactive practice cases designed to sharpen your differential diagnosis skills. I recommend you grab a notebook and actively work through each one using the framework provided before checking the answers.


🩺 Case 1: The Acute Abdomen

Patient: 42-year-old male, previously healthy
Chief Complaint: "My stomach hurts worse than anything I've ever felt."

History:

  • Pain started 8 hours ago as vague periumbilical discomfort, now sharp and localized to RLQ
  • Nausea x3 episodes, no vomiting yet
  • No diarrhea, last BM yesterday
  • No prior surgeries

Vitals: Temp 100.4°F (38°C), HR 110, BP 142/88, RR 18, SpO2 98% RA
Physical Exam:

  • Awake, diaphoretic, moving uncomfortably on stretcher
  • Abdomen: Guarding and rebound tenderness at McBurney's point, diminished bowel sounds
  • Rectal: Normal tone, no masses, guaiac negative

Labs: WBC 14,200 with 85% neutrophils; Hgb 14.2; BMP normal; UA normal; lipase normal

Your Action Steps:

  1. Generate your differential (list 5-7 possibilities ranked by lethality and probability)
  2. Identify the "can't miss" diagnoses
  3. What single test would绝大多数 narrow your differential?
<details> <summary>Click to reveal approach & answer</summary>

Prioritized Differential:

  1. Acute Appendicitis (classic migration pattern, localized peritonitis)
  2. Perforated Duodenal Ulcer (sudden onset, though pain usually epigastric/RUQ)
  3. Cecal Diverticulitis (can mimic appendicitis, older patients usually)
  4. Terminal Ileitis (Crohn's, Yersinia, or infectious)
  5. Ureteral Stone (though pain usually flank→groin, UA would show hematuria)

Can't Miss: Appendiceal perforation with abscess, septic abdominal process

Next Step: CT abdomen/pelvis with IV contrast (or ultrasound if younger/alternative diagnosis needed)

</details>

🫁 Case 2: The Subtle Dyspnea

Patient: 67-year-old female, retired teacher
Chief Complaint: "I just can't catch my breath like I used to."

History:

  • Progressive exertional dyspnea over 6 weeks
  • Dry cough, fatigue, 5 lb unintentional weight loss
  • History: HTN, hypothyroidism (on levothyroxine), 30 pack-year smoking (quit 10 years ago)
  • Meds: Lisinopril, levothyroxine, OTC ibuprofen PRN for back pain

Vitals: Temp 99.1°F, HR 94 irregularly irregular, BP 138/82, RR 20, SpO2 91% on room air
Physical Exam:

  • Thin, elderly female, comfortable at rest
  • Lungs: Fine bibasilar crackles, no wheezing
  • Cardiac: Irregular rhythm, no murmurs, JVP 6 cm
  • Extremities: No edema, no calf tenderness

Labs: Hgb 9.8 (MCV 82), Creatinine 1.4 (baseline 0.9), BNP 450, normal TSH
CXR: Bilateral lower lobe interstitial markings, small bilateral effusions

Your Action Steps:

  1. Create a VINDICATE mnemonic differential (Vascular, Inflammatory, Neoplastic, Degenerative, Idiopathic, Congenital, Autoimmune, Traumatic, Endocrine)
  2. Which finding is the "anchor" that changes everything?
  3. What are your next 2 diagnostic steps?
<details> <summary>Click to reveal approach & answer</summary>

Key Anchor: New anemia (Hgb 9.8) + renal failure (Cr 1.4) + lung findings = Pulmonary-Renal Syndrome

Differential:

  1. Goodpasture's Syndrome (Anti-GBM disease) - linear deposits
  2. Granulomatosis with Polyangiitis (Wegener's) - c-ANCA positive
  3. Microscopic Polyangiitis - p-ANCA positive
  4. SLE (though less common at this age)
  5. Rapidly Progressive Glomerulonephritis (Type III)

Why not CHF? BNP elevated but not sky-high; no peripheral edema; acute renal failure points to systemic vasculitis.

Next Steps:

  1. Urinalysis with microscopy (look for dysmorphic RBCs, RBC casts)
  2. Serologic testing: ANCA, anti-GBM antibodies, ANA, complements
  3. Chest CT (to characterize infiltrates)
  4. Nephrology consult (likely need renal biopsy)
</details>

🌍 Case 3: The Febrile Traveler

Patient: 29-year-old graduate student
Chief Complaint: Fever and "weird spots" for 2 days

History:

  • Returned 10 days ago from 3-week trip to rural Thailand and Cambodia
  • Activities: Jungle trekking, temple visits, street food, unprotected fresh water swimming
  • Symptoms: High fevers (up to 103°F), severe headache, retro-orbital pain, myalgias
  • Rash started on wrists/ankles, spreading centrally (non-itchy)

Vitals: Temp 102.8°F, HR 118, BP 110/70, RR 22
Physical Exam:

  • Ill-appearing, flushed
  • Rash: Maculopapular on extremities, some petechiae on ankles
  • Abdomen: Splenomegaly (2 cm below costal margin), tender
  • Neurologic: Photophobia, neck supple

Labs: WBC 3,200 (low), Platelets 89,000 (low), Hgb 12.1, AST/ALT 120/85, Creatinine 1.2

Your Action Steps:

  1. Geography-based differential: What diseases match Thailand/Cambodia + incubation period?
  2. What finding on blood smear would confirm your diagnosis?
  3. Intervention: Which empiric therapy should start NOW before labs return?
<details> <summary>Click to reveal approach & answer</summary>

Differential (Geographic):

  1. Dengue Fever (classic: fever, thrombocytopenia, transaminitis, rash starting extremities - "breakbone fever")
  2. Malaria (P. vivax or P. falciparum - though usually cyclical fevers, splenomegaly fits)
  3. Scrub Typhus (rural Thailand, eschar may be missed in hairline/groin)
  4. Leptospirosis (fresh water exposure, though usually conjunctival suffusion)
  5. Typhoid Fever (rose spots, relative bradycardia often absent)
  6. Chikungunya (similar to dengue but arthritis prominent)

Key Clues: Timing (10 days post-return), platelet count nadir, transaminitis, rash distribution

Blood Smear: Look for thrombocytopenia with hemoconcentration (HCT rise despite illness). For malaria: ring forms. For dengue: no specific findings but rules out malaria.

Immediate Action:

  • Draw CBC, smear, type & screen (watch for bleeding)
  • Start empiric doxycycline (covers scrub typhus, leptospirosis, rickettsial diseases)
  • IV fluids cautiously (dengue caution: fluid overload risk when defervescence/plasma leak phase hits)
  • Malaria rapid antigen test (stat)
</details>

🎯 Your Clinical Reasoning Framework

For every case you encounter, run through this 5-Step Action Plan:

  1. Anchor & Adjustment: Identify 2-3 objective findings that cannot be ignored (abnormal vitals, specific exam signs), then adjust for patient demographics
  2. Rule Out the Reaper: List the top 3 life-threatening possibilities first (MI, PE, sepsis, intracranial bleed, etc.)
  3. Pattern Recognition: Does this fit a classic presentation? If not, what's atypical?
  4. Probabilistic Reasoning: What is prevalence in this population? (Bayesian thinking)
  5. Test Threshold: What test result would change your management? Don't order if it won't change anything.

To help me tailor more cases for you:

  1. What's your training level? (Pre-clinical, clinical rotations, resident, or practicing clinician looking for CME?)
  2. Which systems challenge you most? (Neuro, infectious disease, rheumatology, etc.)
  3. Do you want cases focused on: Board exam prep, EM/acute care, outpatient ambulatory, or rare zebras?

I can generate 5 more cases in your target area with detailed teaching points on clinical reasoning bias (premature closure, anchoring bias, etc.).